On July 1st, 2023, Google shut down Universal Analytics in favor of GA4 Analytics - a huge blow for marketers that have relied on the previous version for a long time.
The less-than-ideal experience with GA4 has led to a surge in interest in GA4 alternatives. If you've ever considered exploring alternatives to Google Analytics, this is the perfect opportunity to look at other options.
In this article, we compare Google Analytics vs Umami Analytics, a self-hosted and privacy-friendly website analytics tool that could be a good replacement for Google Analytics. We'll also introduce a third alternative.
- What is Umami Analytics used for?
- How does it compare to Google Analytics?
- Umami Analytics Pricing
- Simple Analytics as an alternative for both
- What to look for in an analytics tool
- Final Thoughts
What is Umami Analytics used for?
Umami was created by three brothers, Mike, Brian, and Francis Cao, and is a popular open-source web analytics tool among developers because of its easy deployment. Recently they have also launched a cloud version where Umami manages the hosting.
At first glance, Umami looks good, but you’ll notice that their events feature is elementary, and the data retention policy for the cloud version is very low too. These two caveats make Umami a dealbreaker.
How does it compare to Google Analytics?
There are a few metrics worth looking at when comparing two alternatives. First, we'll dive into the data collection process, then the user interface, usability and compliance.
GA4 focuses on event-based and user-level data collection with a lot of flexibility, tracking a wide set of engagements. Advanced features like "Enhanced measurement" comprehensively track users' activities. However, the data collection method, especially event tracking, may be a bit challenging for beginners to understand and implement.
Umami Analytics provides simple, straightforward site tracking with a more limited set of data points. The simplicity makes it easy to deploy and understand. There are some drawbacks here as well such a the short retention period. In addition, features are really bare bones compared to other analytics tools.
GA4 is a complex analytics tool with a complex interface. It can be overwhelming if you're used to Universal Analytics, especially for beginners.
Umami Analytics boasts a minimalist, uncluttered user interface that is easy to navigate and understand.
GA4 is a powerful, user-centric analytics platform that has a steep learning curve. You will probably require training or work with a developer to get the most important insights form it.
Umami Analytics is a user-friendly platform, focusing on simplicity and clear visual representation of data. It’s less detailed but and more elementary but quicker to understand and use.
Compliance with GDPR and HIPAA:
GA4 aims to be adaptable to cookie-less future, with mechanisms for GDPR compliance. However, various counties have banned the use of Google Analytics based on the data transfers to the U.S. Also GA4 indicated that is not compliant with HIPAA. We wrote about this in depth as well here.
Umami Analytics Pricing
Umami Analytics was initially only open-source but recently launched a hosted cloud version. The pricing starts at $9/month for 100,000 pageviews. One issue with all the plans is that there is no unlimited data retention policy unless you switch to a custom plan.
Simple Analytics as an alternative for both
There is a third alternative that you might want to check out. Especially, if you are fed up with GA4.
Simple Analytics is a privacy-friendly and simple analytics tool, that is 10x easier to use than Google Analytics. It's also one of the few analytics tools that is completely GDPR-compliant with EU-hosted servers.
Now let's review a few benefits of using Simple Analytics.
Pros of using Simple Analytics
- Simplified UI - Simple Analytics offers a straightforward user interface that makes analysis easier. It's 10x easier to work with than GA4. Checkout the public dashboard to see what that looks like.
- Affordable Pricing- Simple Analytics starts at a reasonable price.
- No cookie banner- Simple Analytics gives you the insights you need without using cookies or trackers. Hence, no need for an annoying cookiebanner on your website.
- Chat with your analytics- Simple Analytics AI is the latest features that lets you chat with your analytics and get insights directly.
Cons of using Simple Analytics:
The user interface of Simple Analytics is made to look simple and easy to understand so everyone, be it the founder or marketing teams, can use it easily. A Product Manager may need a few more screens, but that is something that can be quickly built with the goals feature.
Pricing of Simple Analytics:
Simple Analytics is a paid analytics tool unlike Google Analytics. Why? Well, Google Analytics earns money on selling your visitor data. Simple Analytics doesn't do that. We keep your data secure and don't sell it to third-parties.
It comes at a cost, starting at $9/month, making it a pocket-friendly tool for all businesses. There is no reason why website analytics needs to be blantantly pricey.
What to look for in an analytics tool
Selecting a tool for your analytics is a crucial decision. Be sure to go through this checklist before making a choice. You're good to go if the tool provides these:
Ease of Use: You shouldn’t spend your time on a complex web analytics tool that takes time and experience to get familiar with.
Accuracy: Getting an accurate picture of what’s happening on your website is important.
Straightforward UI: Most of the time, you don’t need 75 custom dashboards (looking at you, Google).
Lightweight: Installing an analytics script has an impact on your page speed. Choose an analytics tool that doesn’t slow your website down.
Privacy: The world is moving in a direction where privacy is becoming increasingly important.
Integration: Your analytics should be able to integrate with other tools.
Pricing: Consider the tool's pricing and ensure it aligns with your budget.
Although this checklist can assist you in getting started, there may be other factors for your organization that you need to consider.
If you want a tool that checks these boxes, then check out Simple Analytics. It provides the insights you need in a straightforward dashboard while being 100% GDPR compliant.
Want to see what that looks like? Check our public dashboard here
We believe the internet should be an independent place that is friendly to website visitors. By opting for Simple Analytics, you’ll be supporting us in our mission and protecting the privacy of your website visitors. If this resonates with you, feel free to give us a try.